by Flying Cloud
Issue by Matt: Women umpires in the AFL?
“League encourages girls umpires”
What is actually your thoughts on this piece of function? I have received no difficulties at all with them being objective umpires, but boundary and area umpires are a little bit of a concern for me.
As it is now the commentators are currently stating how very poor the toss-ins are when they drop limited, and it happens a honest little bit. What is actually likely to occur when they begin receiving women umpires to toss it in? A lady will not have the upper human body energy of a guy.
As discipline umpires, I get the emotion they would be as well squeamish. I believe instinctively they will give absent far more soft cost-free kicks than the male umpires do. Females tend to believe “Ooh that would’ve hurt” a whole lot much more than men and I think this would carry over into the choice producing, probably biasing them. It would be hard to alter a woman’s complete mentality in umpiring school.
I am not getting sexist or something but I feel they should hold them as goal umpires and powering the scenes, they do a good task already. What is your thoughts? Great idea? Negative concept? Woman legal rights movements gone too far?
Very best response:
Answer by Saints.female
I dont think there need to be feminine umps, im a woman and i dont consider that it would operate for i dont believe they would be ready to have the aurthority in excess of the gamers they are going to get abused which for plenty of ladies will make them cry, and also your readons of throwing the ball in.
All in all i dont feel it is a excellent thought
What do you feel? Solution under!